How to Win More Real Estate Appraisals and Listings
By Christian Bartley | Founder, Real Mentor
I want you to think about your last five listing presentations.
How many did you win?
And more importantly, do you know why you won the ones you did and why you missed the others?
Throughout my career, I personally achieved an appraisal-to-listing conversion rate of approximately 84%.
That wasn't because I was always the cheapest.
It wasn't because I promised the highest price.
And it certainly wasn't because I had the fanciest presentation.
It came down to having a clear process, understanding the people I was sitting in front of, demonstrating genuine value and giving property owners confidence in what I could deliver.
The systems and processes I developed were shared and taught throughout Bellarine Property. But here's something I've always believed: you can give ten agents the same system, but how they deliver it will never be exactly the same.
Everyone has their own personality, communication style and way of building relationships.
The key is having a proven process behind you, while learning how to deliver it in a way that's natural and authentic to you.
And that's exactly what I teach agents today.
Stop presenting and start understanding
One of the biggest mistakes I see agents make is walking into an appraisal and immediately starting to talk.
They talk about their company, their sales results, their marketing, their database and everything they're going to do.
But there's something missing.
They haven't properly understood the person sitting in front of them.
Before you start telling someone what you can do, you need to understand what they're trying to achieve.
Why are they considering selling?
Where are they going?
What's their timeframe?
What's important to them?
What concerns do they have?
What would a successful result actually look like?
The answers to these questions should shape your entire presentation.
The listing presentation should be a conversation
I teach agents to structure their appraisals around a clear agenda.
We cover motivation, questions, performance, fees and pricing, the sales process, marketing and the next steps.
But it's not about ticking boxes.
It's about making sure the owner understands what you're recommending and why.
For example, rather than simply presenting a marketing schedule, explain how your marketing will attract buyers, generate inspections and create competition.
Don't just show them a list of recent sales.
Explain what those sales tell you about the current market and how they influence your recommended strategy.
And don't be afraid to discuss the difficult questions.
That's often where your value becomes obvious.
Be different for a reason
Here's something I want agents to think about.
If three agents walk into the same property and all three say roughly the same thing, how is the owner supposed to choose?
They're probably going to compare fees, marketing costs and suggested selling prices.
That's not where you want the decision to be made.
You need to demonstrate a genuine point of difference.
It might be your buyer management process, your communication, your campaign structure, your negotiation strategy or the preparation you undertake before launching a property.
Whatever it is, make sure it's something you can actually deliver.
Being different isn't about being clever.
It's about giving the owner a genuine reason to choose you.
Don't leave the close to chance
Another mistake I see is agents delivering a great presentation and then walking out without asking for the business.
They hope the owner will call them.
Hope isn't a strategy.
You need to understand whether the owner is ready to make a decision, whether they have concerns and what needs to happen next.
Ask the questions.
Have the conversation.
And give them the opportunity to move forward.
Your next action
Before your next appraisal, write down the five questions you want answered before you begin presenting.
Then consider this:
If you removed your company name and logo from your presentation, would there be anything that genuinely separates you from the other agents?
If the answer is no, you've got some work to do.
The good news is, that's something you can change.
Christian Bartley
Founder, Real Mentor
Real Mentor provides practical real estate appraisal and sales training for agents and agencies looking to improve listing presentations, conversion and overall performance.
Win more of the appraisals you attend
Work with Christian on listing presentations, conversion and delivering a proven process in your own authentic way.